Rent vs. Buy a Home: The 5% Rule & True Break-Even Horizon

Loans & Mortgages 8 min read Updated November 18, 2026

The cliché "renting is throwing money away" ignores one huge reality: homeownership also carries massive unrecoverable costs—mortgage interest, property taxes, homeowners insurance, maintenance, HOA dues, and closing fees that build zero equity.

The 5% Rule: Apples-to-Apples Monthly Comparison

Portfolio managers often apply the 5% Rule to check whether local home prices are cheap or expensive relative to rents:

  • ~1% annually in unrecoverable property taxes
  • ~1% annually in ongoing repairs, roofs, HVAC, and maintenance
  • ~3% annually in mortgage interest & down-payment opportunity cost

Example on a $450,000 Home:

($450,000 × 5%) ÷ 12 = $1,875 / month in unrecoverable owner costs. If you can rent an equivalent home for $1,650/month and faithfully invest the difference + down payment, renting can come out ahead over short horizons.

Why Holding Period Changes Everything

Selling a home typically costs 6%–8% in agent commissions, transfer taxes, and prep work—on top of 2%–4% buyer closing costs upfront. On a $400,000 house, that round-trip friction exceeds $36,000. Check your exact city numbers inside the Rent vs. Buy Calculator and verify monthly comfort with the House Affordability Calculator and Rent Calculator.

Run Your Own Numbers

Compare net worth outcomes over 5 to 30 years factoring home appreciation, taxes, and S&P 500 opportunity cost.

Run Rent vs. Buy Simulation →

Frequently asked questions

What is the 5% Rule for renting vs. buying?▶
Multiply a home's price by 5% and divide by 12 to estimate unrecoverable monthly ownership costs (property tax ~1%, maintenance ~1%, and cost of capital/interest ~3%). If you can rent a similar property for less than that figure, renting may build more wealth if you invest the savings.
How long do I typically need to own a home to break even?▶
Because buyer + seller closing costs and realtor commissions consume 7%–10% of property value round-trip, buying usually takes 5 to 7+ years to outperform renting financially.